top of page

Consolidating Debt Into Your Mortgage? Compare More Than the Monthly Payment

Writer: Cait  Holmes
Cait Holmes
1 day ago
4 min read

By Cait Holmes, Mortgage Designers | Nanaimo, B.C.


When several debt payments land in the same week, it can feel as though your paycheque is spoken for before it arrives. A credit card, a personal loan and a line of credit may each be manageable on their own. Together, they can leave very little room for groceries, repairs or savings.


If you own a home, refinancing to consolidate some of those balances may be an option. A lower interest rate or a longer repayment period could reduce the monthly amount you need to pay.


Before making that change, though, look at the full transaction. You’re deciding how much to borrow against your home, what it costs to arrange and how long you’ll take to repay it.


Here’s how to make that comparison.


Start with a complete list of debts


Gather current statements showing each balance, interest rate, required payment and any payout conditions.


Check whether a promotional rate is ending, whether a loan has a fixed payoff date and whether its interest rate is already competitive. Different debts can deserve different treatment.


For example, a credit card charging a high rate may be a stronger candidate for consolidation than a low-rate vehicle loan nearing its final payment. Moving both into a mortgage could simplify the paperwork while extending repayment on debt that would otherwise disappear soon.


Also check what caused the balances to grow. Was there a temporary income interruption, a major repair or a recurring gap between income and spending?


That answer matters when building the budget after refinancing. If normal expenses still exceed income, the cleared credit cards could begin filling up again.


Work out how much equity could be available


Home equity is the difference between the property’s value and the amounts secured against it.

For ordinary home-equity borrowing, FCAC says financial institutions may usually allow total borrowing up to 80 per cent of the home’s value. The available amount also depends on existing secured debt and lender approval.


Suppose a home is appraised at $800,000 and has a $500,000 mortgage, with no other secured borrowing.


Eighty per cent of $800,000 is $640,000. Subtracting the mortgage leaves $140,000 before transaction costs and any other adjustments.


That is an illustration of equity capacity. The lender still needs to assess income, credit, debts and the property. An online estimate or property tax assessment can also differ from the value accepted for financing.


Start with a realistic value range and confirm what appraisal or other valuation the lender requires.


Ask for the cost of changing the whole mortgage


If you refinance before maturity, there may be a charge to pay out the existing mortgage. Legal, appraisal, discharge or other transaction costs may also apply.


Ask for a written breakdown and confirm whether each cost will be paid from savings, deducted from proceeds or added to the borrowing.


Then compare the interest rate on the existing mortgage with the proposed rate. If the transaction replaces your current mortgage, the new pricing affects that balance as well as the additional debt.

Imagine you want to consolidate $35,000. The calculation needs to account for the cost of replacing a $500,000 mortgage too.


Timing can matter. If renewal is approaching, ask for a comparison between refinancing now and considering the change at maturity. Include what the unsecured debts would cost during the wait.


Separate payment relief from the repayment timeline


A smaller monthly payment can provide breathing room. It can also result partly from spreading repayment over more years.


Consider $30,000 of debt. Before interest, repaying that amount over five years requires $500 a month. Spread over 25 years, the principal alone averages $100 a month.


The lower monthly commitment is clear. So is the much longer repayment period.


For a useful comparison, ask for projections showing:

  • The required payment under the proposed refinance.

  • The balance expected at the end of the mortgage term.

  • A payment plan that repays the consolidated portion on a shorter schedule.


Future mortgage rates will affect longer-term results, so a projection should state its assumptions.


Compare options over the same period and include the remaining debt at the end.


Build a plan for the cash flow you free up


Suppose your household currently pays $2,800 toward the mortgage and $900 toward other debts. Total monthly debt payments are $3,700.


A hypothetical refinance produces a $3,100 mortgage payment after the selected debts are paid out.


That leaves $600 a month compared with the previous required payments.


These figures are illustrative, but they create a practical question. Where will that $600 go?


You might allocate some to irregular expenses, some to a cash reserve and some to additional mortgage payments permitted by the contract. Write the amounts into the budget before the refinance closes.


If the goal is to repay the consolidated debt faster, ask how to track that progress. Even when everything sits within one mortgage balance, you can maintain a separate repayment target and review it regularly.


Request a comparison you can follow


Bring your broker the latest mortgage statement, debt statements, income documents and an outline of your monthly expenses.


Ask to see the current arrangement beside the proposed refinance, including all costs, payments and projected balances over a common period.


A useful decision may involve consolidating selected balances, changing the timing or adjusting the amount borrowed. The numbers should show what each choice means for your household.


If you’re considering debt consolidation in Nanaimo or elsewhere in B.C., we can work through the options together. Reach me at www.caitholmes.ca.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page